ZAMAN! when I came as a "refugee" in 2006 to the USA, besides the DHS, zaman was amongst the organization that helped us immensely, providing some furniture and even getting us a van to help in daily necessary transportation. 15 years later, I'm a 27 year old engineer who has finalized our house mortgage just last year, and now I'm giving back to the institutions that helped us through taxes and of course donations to the poor. Immigration is a good thing, I hope Americans see this as evidence. We middle eastern folks dont aim to siphon off of food stamps and government assistance, were too proud to ever do that. Our aim is just to get on our feet momentarily and intend to give back surely
Why: Former Zaman beneficiary with a concrete success story โ engineer, mortgage paid off, now giving back. This is the entire video's thesis proven in real life. Pinning this reply could turn the thread viral and is the single best social proof in the comments.
Draft replyThis is exactly the story Najah is building toward โ thank you for sharing it. Mortgage paid off, giving back, 15 years later. That's Zaman working.
Where can i get the cookies? Link please
Why: Unanswered direct question with 629 likes โ hundreds of people want the same answer and no one replied. Easy win, drives real traffic to Zaman.
Draft replyLinks are in the description โ they're working on Whole Foods distribution right now. Once that lands I'll post an update.
This is what Fox News doesn't show about Muslims in America
Why: 631 likes and taps directly into the 19.6% 'Muslims and media bias' comment cluster โ the most politically charged audience segment. A measured reply here anchors the thread and discourages it from going negative.
Draft replyThat's kind of the whole point of coming here โ there's a lot that doesn't make the cut on any cable channel. Najah is the story.
@weareallbrainwashed5101 ยท mediumโ view Imagine this woman here in USA, and Jenner wins the woman of the year, and the media glorifying the Kardashian's.
Why: 821 likes โ third most-liked comment. Sharp cultural contrast that resonates broadly. A reply keeps the spotlight on Najah rather than the comparison.
Draft replyShe's been doing this for 20 years and most people have never heard of her. Hopefully that changes.
I volunteered at Zaman for a couple months and it was such an amazing experience. Its difficult not to cry listening to this incredible woman! Her mission, dedication and vision have been my source of inspiration!
Why: First-hand volunteer testimony โ exactly what potential donors and volunteers need to hear. Replying surfaces this in the thread and could recruit more volunteers.
Draft replyReally appreciate you sharing that โ having someone say 'I was actually there and it's real' means more than anything I can film.
Gal was my neighbor growing up, her husband would always welcome the neighborhood children to their home and coach us all in basketball. Cannot say enough good things about her and her family.
Why: Personal community connection to Gal, Zaman's first hire โ humanizes the organization beyond Najah and could be shared with Gal herself as morale.
Draft replyThat's a beautiful detail โ Najah lit up when she talked about Gal. Pass this along to her if you ever get the chance.
I LOVE this content. I'd love to see Peter visit some Native American reservations next. Maybe a less touristy one(although similar with the Amish IDK how much you can remove the tourist aspect of the equation).
Why: Content request from an engaged fan with a specific, actionable idea โ good to acknowledge publicly so the audience sees the creator listens.
Draft replyThat's on the list โ the reservation angle is one I've been thinking about. Less curated access is harder to get but that's exactly the point.
I like her and her perspective on this situation, but when she said, "refugee's are coming soon..." I know it's not her fault but we have to stop taking so-called "refugee's" when we cannot even take care of our own.
Why: Fair, non-hostile pushback from someone who actually liked the video โ the 'take care of our own first' argument is widespread and worth a factual response. WeyardWiz's comment is a perfect natural counter.
Draft replyNajah's point โ and I think she's right โ is that refugees tend to come with skills and work ethic, not to drain resources. Check the top comment on this video for a real example.
Poor people make poor decisions. If you are poor, stop having children you cannot financially take care of on your own. Put the bottle down. Stop smoking herb and cigarettes. Invest in yourself, with a skill. Plumbers, welders, electricians etc do damn well. You do not "need" college. 24 hours in a day. You sleep for 6 or 7. Work 8. Leaves 9 hours a day. Oh but you want to watch tv, play Madden, chill out. So whats your excuse?
Why: Provocative but not entirely wrong โ the video itself touches on personal accountability. Worth a brief reply that redirects to the 'four types' nuance without validating the dismissiveness.
Draft replyNajah actually agrees with you on some of this โ she talks about the four categories and says you can't lump everyone together. The women in that building are making the choice to change. That's exactly who she's there for.
Why are the views on this series so different from the amish series ๐
Why: Viewer concern about the channel's reach โ shows they care and are invested. Worth a one-liner to acknowledge the algorithm reality without making it weird.
Draft replyDifferent audiences, different algorithms โ that's just how it goes. The people who find this one tend to stick around though.
I like your content. It would interesting if you interviewed African-American Muslims that were followers of the Hon. Elijah Muhammad, but transitioned to sunni or traditional practice of Islam who following his son WD Muhammed after Elijah passed.
Why: Specific, well-informed content suggestion that fits the Muslim America series โ acknowledging it publicly signals the creator does historical research.
Draft replyThat transition is a massive and underreported story โ W.D. Mohammed's influence especially. Adding it to the list.
GREAT JOB PETER! KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK ๐๐ SAILING ACROSS THE ATLANTIC LOVING YOUR STORIES โต๏ธ MY TEXT IS STUCK ON CAPโฆ IM NOT YELLING ๐คฃ๐๐คฃ๐
Why: Devoted fan watching from a sailboat mid-Atlantic โ the kind of specific detail that makes a public reply memorable and humanizes the audience.
Draft replyWatching from the Atlantic โ that might be the best viewing situation anyone's ever described. Stay safe out there.